What happens if I overprice my house?
The short answer: Overpricing can cost you showings. Buyers comparing homes in the same price range may never schedule a visit if yours appears to offer less value. Fewer showings mean fewer opportunities for offers, and the home may remain on the market longer. Your opening price should have a clear explanation based on your home, the competing listings, recent sales, and your goals.
Sellers often ask me, “Why not start high and leave room to negotiate?” Sometimes a distinctive property supports a higher asking price. But a price set mainly to test the market may cause buyers to compare your home with stronger choices in that price range. You can adjust later, but you cannot recreate the first impression buyers had when the listing launched.
Watch Larry’s explanation
Ten ways overpricing can affect a sale
Fewer buyers may visit
Buyers weighing similar homes may skip one that appears expensive for its size, condition, or location.
The home may take longer to sell
When qualified buyers pass, the listing can remain active while new competing homes enter the market.
Offers may be fewer or farther below asking
Some buyers will wait for a price change; others may offer according to the comparable sales they trust.
Interest can concentrate elsewhere
A well-priced alternative can attract attention while an otherwise appealing home waits for the right buyer.
You may miss some buyers’ searches
A buyer filtering listings below a price ceiling may never see a home priced just above it. Search behavior varies by site and buyer.
Buyers may question the asking price
If the price looks out of line with competing homes, buyers may wonder whether there is room for a productive negotiation.
Your home enters a tougher comparison set
At a higher price point, buyers may expect features or condition that nearby alternatives provide.
A workable deal may become harder to reach
Less buyer engagement means fewer chances to compare offer terms and find a buyer whose timing fits yours.
Ownership costs continue
Taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and any mortgage payments continue while the home remains unsold.
Your eventual net may be lower
A later price reduction combined with additional carrying costs can reduce proceeds. It is a possibility, not an automatic outcome.
A Naperville listing I worked on
A Naperville home I represented was initially offered at a price I believed was above the range most likely to attract buyers ($769,900). Showing activity was limited during that listing. Several months later, the home was offered at a lower asking price through another agent and went under contract in about two weeks. It ultimately closed for the asking price of $730,000.
While the list price is ultimately the seller’s decision, this experience reinforces why I discuss pricing and an early review plan with sellers before a listing goes live. It does not prove what would have happened at a different initial price: timing, presentation, competing homes, and the buyers active at each point may also have mattered.
How to set a price you can defend
- Compare recent closed sales, then account for meaningful differences in condition, layout, lot, location, and timing.
- Look at active competition to understand what buyers can choose today. Asking prices are evidence of competition, not proof of sale value.
- Decide what matters most to you: maximum proceeds, a reliable closing date, less preparation, or a balance of those goals.
- Agree in advance on when you will review showings, feedback, offers, and new comparable sales.
There is no universal percentage above which a home is “overpriced.” A pricing recommendation should explain the evidence and the tradeoffs for your particular property.
Questions sellers ask me
Does a higher list price leave room to negotiate?
It can, but only if buyers still see enough value to visit and make an offer. The size of the negotiating cushion should be weighed against the risk of losing qualified interest.
How soon should I consider a price change?
There is no fixed number of days for every home. Review the volume and quality of showings, buyer feedback, new competing listings, and current sales against the plan you set before listing.
Will a price reduction make my home look undesirable?
Buyers may notice it, but a well-supported new price can also bring the home into more relevant searches. The reason for the change and the strength of the presentation matter.
Next guide: How should I price my house before listing?
“Your Marketing Matters”
Wondering where your home fits?
I can walk through the comparable sales, current competition, likely preparation choices, and a pricing range for your goals. You’ll understand the reasoning before you decide what to do.
Text or call 630-921-0611 or email Lshakman@reo-property.com.
Keep the practical answers handy.
Get a complimentary PDF of my book, The Top 10’s of Real Estate, with insights for sellers, buyers, and investors.
